Our Favorite Long Island Christmas Tree Farms

There’s nothing quite like kicking off the holiday season with a fresh-cut Christmas tree—and on Long Island, we’re lucky to have some of the best family-run tree farms right in our backyard. Whether you love the tradition of cutting your own tree, sipping hot cocoa while you browse, or taking the kids for photos with Santa, these farms offer something special for everyone.

Here are our favorite Long Island Christmas Tree Farms to explore this holiday season:

1. Santa’s Christmas Tree Farm – Cutchogue

A North Fork classic, Santa’s Christmas Tree Farm is packed with holiday cheer from the moment you arrive. Families love the festive atmosphere, photo-friendly décor, and visits from Santa himself. Whether you want to cut your own or choose from pre-cut trees, this farm makes the entire experience magical.

Why we love it:

🎅 Santa visits

🌲 Cut-your-own options

📸 Tons of holiday photo ops

2. Lewin Farms – Calverton

Lewin Farms is a long-standing Suffolk County staple known for its sprawling fields and wide tree selection. If your family loves the traditional Christmas tree experience—saws, wagons, the whole thing—this is your spot.

Why we love it:

🌲 Huge variety

🪓 Authentic cut-your-own experience

🚜 Great for outdoorsy families

3. Waterdrinker Farm – Manorville

Waterdrinker Farm is one of Long Island’s most Instagram-worthy destinations. Known for their year-round festivals, their Christmas season does not disappoint. Expect beautiful décor, fun holiday activities, and plenty for kids to explore.

Why we love it:

🎄 Beautiful, festive displays

🐐 Family-friendly activities

📍 A fun day trip destination

4. Carter’s Christmas Tree Farm – Miller Place

A local favorite for Northern Brookhaven families, Carter’s offers a more quiet, cozy farm experience. Their trees are well cared for, and the staff is always friendly and helpful.

Why we love it:

🌲 High-quality trees

🤝 Supportive, family-run business

✨ Low-key and relaxed

5. Fink’s Country Farm – Calverton

Fink’s is known for its fall festival, but its Christmas season is just as charming. Expect pre-cut trees, wreaths, decorations, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

Why we love it:

🌲 Great tree selection

🎁 Holiday décor & farm store

🐴 Seasonal wagon rides (varies by year)

6. Zuhoski Tree Farm – Cutchogue

This North Fork farm offers beautiful, well-shaped trees and a simple, traditional atmosphere. It’s a wonderful spot if you prefer a laid-back cut-your-own experience.

Why we love it:

🌲 Long-lasting trees

🌾 Classic, peaceful farm feel

🧤 Great for families looking to avoid crowds

7. Elwood Pumpkin & Christmas Tree Farm – Elwood

Located in Western Suffolk, Elwood is perfect if you don’t want to travel too far east. Their pre-cut and cut-your-own options make it easy, and the staff is known for being warm and helpful.

Why we love it:

🎄 Convenient location

🌲 Mix of pre-cut & cut-your-own

✨ Friendly atmosphere

Make It a Holiday Tradition

Whether you’re a “cut-your-own” family or love browsing pre-cut varieties, Long Island has no shortage of farms to explore. These local businesses work hard to bring holiday magic to our community—and visiting one of them each year is a tradition worth keeping.

Protect What Matters Most This Holiday Season

As you’re out making memories—picking the perfect tree, decorating your home, and enjoying the magic of the season—make sure your family and your business are protected.

At The Daley Agency Inc., we help Long Island families and business owners stay covered year-round with personalized insurance solutions designed for real life. Our team is here to give you peace of mind during the holidays and beyond.

🎁 Need an insurance review before the new year? Let’s make sure you’re fully covered heading into 2026.Contact us today for a complimentary policy review.